Skip to main content

Housing officers "conspired to evict tenant unlawfully", High Court rules

 

Housing officers "conspired to evict tenant unlawfully", High Court rules

Details

16.Oct.2014

Officers at a London borough conspired to evict a social housing tenant of 23 years standing unlawfully and arranged for his possessions to be destroyed, a High Court judge has found.

Southwark Council has subsequently apologised to the unnamed claimant and settled his claim for damages.

In AA v London Borough of Southwark [2014] EWHC 500 (QB) the claimant had been a tenant of the flat in issue since 2001.

His rent was mainly paid by housing benefit, save for a weekly shortfall that by 2012 had reached £18.59 per week. Throughout the period, the claimant had been in arrears since the shortfall was only paid in part and intermittently. The arrears at the time of the eviction amounted to £2,353.26.

In 2006 a possession order was made. This was subsequently suspended by a succession of four orders culminating in one dated 6 May 2010.

These required the claimant to meet his current weekly rent liability and pay off the arrears in small weekly instalments. Nothing was paid following the last of these orders and Southwark applied for the execution of a warrant for possession.

AA unsuccessfully applied for that warrant to be suspended and it was executed on 23 April 2013. The entire contents of the claimant's flat including his passport, lap tops, papers, personal belongings and furniture were removed from the flat by the local authority and were taken to and destroyed in a refuse disposal facility.

The claimant made repeated unsuccessful attempts in the High Court and county court to regain possession and to regain his belongings and also made repeated unsuccessful attempts to discuss his predicament with various representatives of Southwark.

AA was for a period of over a year street homeless and without financial resources save for the use of a sofa or floor space in accommodation of friends for part of this period and financial assistance from those friends.

He sued Southwark for reinstatement and for substantial damages for his unlawful eviction, unlawful homelessness and for the unlawful destruction of his possessions based on the torts of conspiracy, interference with goods, negligence and misfeasance in public office, breaches of the terms of his contractual tenancy and pursuant to the Human Rights Act under Article 8 of the ECHR.

Providing a summary of his judgment, His Honour Judge Anthony Thornton QC, sitting as a deputy judge of the High Court, said the starting point was a conspiracy involving three employees in Southwark’s housing department “to the effect that the claimant should be evicted at all costs and without the opportunity to obtain a further suspension of the possession order obtained in November 2006”.

The judge explained that since the order had been suspended more than six years before the council wished to execute it, Southwark was not entitled to apply for a warrant, an administrative procedure that did not involve a judge, without first obtaining permission to apply from a judge.

“Having obtained the warrant, the defendant's housing officer failed to place the full facts of the case to the court at the hearing of the claimant's application for a further suspension,” he said.

“The conspiracy also involved the relevant defendant's housing officers short-circuiting the defendant's standard procedures that should have been followed before and during the execution of the warrant and the taking of a dispossessed tenant's possessions into storage for safe-keeping.”

Judge Thornton said these procedures were intended to ensure that any execution of a warrant for possession was fairly, safely and lawfully undertaken.

“The conspiracy continued as an attempted cover-up of the unlawful nature of the original conspiracy and of the unlawful consequences of that conspiracy that had led to the claimant's unlawful eviction, the destruction of the claimant's possessions and his homelessness without financial resources for a lengthy period,” the judge added.

He pointed out that it had been a requirement “for many years” that a landlord must apply to a judge for permission to apply for a warrant for possession if the original possession order had been made more than six years prior to the order even if the order had been suspended by a judge on terms that had not been complied with in the intervening period.

The judgment confirmed that the decisions of the Court of Appeal in Hackney LBC v White (1996) 28 HLR 219 and Patel v Singh [2002] EWCA Civ 1938 and the underlying CCR were applicable to Southwark's application for a warrant in this case and to the claimant's eviction pursuant to that warrant.

Judge Thornton found that the council’s contention that the 6-year period only started to run after an order in Hassan form further suspending the possession order had been made on 20 February 2007 was unsustainable. The warrant and its execution were, on that ground alone, unlawful.

The judge concluded that:

  1. The eviction was unlawful and an abuse of process “both because the warrant was issued without the prior permission of the court and in the manner in which it was executed”;
  2. The various officers in Southwark’s housing department conspired to evict the claimant by unlawful means, to seize and destroy his possessions by unlawful means and to cause him harm and loss be evicting him of his possessions by unlawful means. “This conspiracy was subsequently covered up by a further conspiracy which gave rise to abuse of process in the subsequent court proceedings and to a continuing deprivation of the claimant's enjoyment of his tenancy and loss of his possessions”;
  3. Three officers exercised their powers as public officers in relation to a local authority secure tenancy “for an improper motive with the intention of harming the claimant by having him evicted when there were no reasonable grounds for his eviction and by arranging for his possessions to be seized and destroyed unlawfully”;
  4. The claimant had, as a result of these facts, also been caused loss “by the negligence of the council, by its breach of his right to the quiet enjoyment of his tenancy and as a result of the lack of respect shown to his private life by the defendant”;
  5. The claimant was entitled to substantial damages that extended to special or general damages, aggravated and exemplary damages and damages for breach of contract and for the various torts he had been subject to and for equitable remuneration for the lost work stored on his hard drives, discs and memory sticks and for his lost photographs as well as a remedy for the loss of his tenancy on a basis still to be determined.

The remedies and damages to be awarded were to be dealt with at a second trial. However, Southwark has since reached a confidential settlement with the claimant.

Cllr Richard Livin`gstone, Cabinet Member for Housing, said: "As a council we realise we got things very wrong when dealing with this person and their possessions. We have apologised for any distress we may have caused and do so again following the High Court judgment. We acted swiftly and took strong disciplinary action against our staff when this came to our attention and we have also settled the claim against us.

"We have also looked closely at our procedures to try to ensure that there is no repeat of this highly unusual, but very distressing, scenario in the future. Poor treatment of tenants and residents is totally unacceptable and we will be reviewing the judgment very closely to see if there is any further action we need to take."


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

25 Oct 2025 Ryan v SSWP or Ryan v Cambridge City Council.

I have a dilemma I have only so many spoons. Do I make another High Court Claim for CCC or SSWP or do I just report Carla B to the police? You have my permission to use AI to read this post. I have decided to put a criminal case together for Carla B, the Customer Service Team Leader in the Cambridge Job Centre. I have never done criminal law before. But I do know if two white police officers from Parkside come to your home, to hand deliver a letter, and read it to you (perhaps because you are dyslexic) so that the can personally tell you  that they will not investigate the racist comments made that you  recorded. This is because they asked them and they sad they did not say that. But importantly the police officers have their cameras on, without telling you for their protection (without telling you) which is very criminal. So you smile and show them your partner watching on the IPAD, and later ask for the Video via GDPR. That sort of crime is obvious because is it is very...

Formal complaint to GLD DWP, SRA, and Cilex,

Formal complaint to GLD DWP, SRA, and Cilex, Dated 12 June 2026 by email  Encl 9 June 2025 DWP Submission to high court by GLD DWP stating that email cannot be used. 25 June 2025 Cambridge email identifying me by email Dear GLD, SRA and Cilex I am writing to complain about the GLD DWP staff interfering in my claim for disability access to Universal Credit. Ironically, to deny my access to UC, they are also denying me access to a court. As well as misleading me, they have misled DWP staff in jobcentres. This has likely led to deaths because the advice was woefully incorrect. My guess is that say whatever they want, because they have the court. This is based on a first-hand conversation from the court staff and the outrageous claims made. Expanded below, these quotes are wrong in law. PIP regulation 88 does not exist. They claim that the DWP is immune from the Equality Act 2010. And that because the DWP is an employer t...

Cambridgeshire police still have not logged my complaint about harassment

 I made two major complaints and sent a letter before action.  One issues is Cambridgshire police failing to investigate crimes, silently closing them, and then hiding the reasons with redactions. They close these crime reports in way so I cannot use the victims right to review. Below is the visit I received after asking for my data about criminal complaints about Daniel Reynard. The police closed criminal reports for the 31 Oct 2025. The one where Daniel Reynard lied about me having no health or universal credit problems on 11 Sept 2026 . In response to my asking about what happened I get a lot of  visits from the police. 0400, 0500, 1000. These visits started 5 May until Sept 2026. The do not say why they are there. In between this I get a visit from Daniel Reynard  8 July 2026 delivering a letter before action.  This clip is of two policeman on 24 August 2026. I believe Cambridgeshire police. You will notice there is no mention or a warrant for arrest, warran...